Lucky Penny

Author: Catherine Anderson
Publisher: Penguin Group/Signet
Pub. Date: January 31, 2012
ISBN-13: 978-0451236036
Pages: 432
Digital Price: $7.99
Print Retail Price: $7.99
Amazon ~ B&N ~ iBookstore

To support her orphaned niece, impoverished Brianna O’Keefe accepts work with a Colorado rancher. To guard herself from unwanted attention, she resorts to a harmless little lie: that she’s married to a Denver gold miner named David Paxton. When her boss forces her to write her “husband,” hoping he’ll take Brianna off his hands, she can only pray that there is no real David Paxton who can expose her.

When Colorado marshal David Paxton gets a letter from a stranger claiming to be his wife and pleading with him to come for her and his daughter, he dutifully sets out to find this woman and the child he may have sired. What stuns Brianna’s wary attraction blossoms into deeper desire, David warms to the idea of a ready-made family. But can his dream survive Brianna’s lingering distrust—and his own secrets?

~*~*~

REVIEW

David Paxton’s pleasant life as a marshal in No Name, Colorado is disrupted when he receives a letter from a stranger claiming to be his wife and asking him to help her and their daughter. Brianna O’Keefe has make up a story that she is married to a gold miner named “David Paxton”. Suddenly, events spiral out of control and she agrees to live as David’s wife to keep custody of her orphaned niece Daphne.

I liked the character of David form the very beginning of the book. He is loyal, brave, tender, and tough. He reminds me of Rhett Butler, Indiana Jones, and John Wayne all rolled into one! I wasn’t as quick to appreciate Brianna. David says it best when he says she is “the human equivalent of a prickly pear.” I realize she was raised in a convent, but I got tired of her constantly correcting David’s grammar and complaining about his foul language. As David comes to care about Brianna, and I started looking at her through his eyes, I began to like her so much more. Her prim exterior hides someone that had to become tough to survive adversity and will do anything to protect Daphne, and this is admirable.

This isn’t the first time a plot of a romance novel includes a marriage of convenience that has the potential to lead to true love. However, I think Catherine Anderson puts a fresh spin on it. David is determined to do the right thing by his daughter and her mother, and doesn’t realize Brianna is really telling the truth when she tells him he isn’t Daphne’s father. It’s sweet to see them slowing becoming a loving, if unconventional family, even if it does take a while. There are some steamy love scenes toward the end, but David and Brianna spend most of the book arguing and misjudging the other, while sneaking in an admiring glance here and there.

I don’t mind the slow build and the romance works for me. However, the historical part of the book could be better. I’m not historian by any means, but many of the things the characters say and do don’t seem to fit with the times. I just don’t think things like “awesome” and “no worries” were common expressions in 1891. A great historical novel transports you to another time and place, but this book didn’t have that effect on me. It seemed more like modern characters put in costumes and placed on horseback. That being said, the book has an interesting plot and likeable characters, especially David and his family. So, overall, I think it is a good book even though the 1890s atmosphere wasn’t as realistic as I would have liked.

Rating: 3.5 (Good)

Heat-Level: 3.5 (Sensual/Hot)

Reviewed by Christine K.

Comment and enter to win your own copy of LUCKY PENNY.

3.5 Starshistoricals
By Reviews, Signet/NAL28 Comments on Review & Giveaway: Lucky Penny by Catherine Anderson

28 Replies to “Review & Giveaway: Lucky Penny by Catherine Anderson”

  3. I recently read my first Catherine Anderson book, Annie’s Song and fell for it. I can tell this author’s stories are going to be ones I can connect with emotionally. Thank you for the chance to read “Lucky Penny”.

  6. I have never read any of Catherine’s books, but would love to win this so that I can start reading them.

  10. Even though I love the lands of England, this sounds like a good book. 🙂 Thanks for the great review Christine.

  11. Great review Christine. I love marriage of convenience stories and this one does sound different and good!

  13. I like historicals with a western setting. I agree with you that an author should attempt to stay as true as possible to the time period and characters as possible in an historical. If they are off, it throws the flow of the story off. It still sounds like a story I will enjoy. I’ll make room for it on the shelf with my other Catherine Anderson books.

  14. I generally enjoy books by Catherine Anderson. I’d love to read LUCKY PENNY thank you.

  15. I have not tried any of Catherine Anderson’s books. This story LUCKY PENNY sounds like one that I would enjoy reading. Very touching storyline wit the niece and the lonely marshall..

  16. This sounds like a great book. Can’t wait to read it. Thanks for the giveaway.

    e.balinski(at)att(dot)net

  19. I really enjoy Catherine Anderson’s books. The blurb sounds good, as does your review for the most part. Too bad there wasn’t a better editor to catch the errors you mentioned.

  20. I like Catherine’s books, they’re the kind of books I reread A LOT 🙂
    Thanks for this :*

  21. I haven’t read books by Catherine but I’m interested now. I’d love to start reading now. The story is heartwarming.

  22. I’ve seen her book, but never tried it before, looks interseting and the review sounds good. I might have to try it. Thanks!

  24. I like the blurb about the book, sounds like it has potential. But when historicals use modern language it really bothers me. Distracts me from the story, unless there is some paranormal reason for people to talk like they are from our time. Guessing that would be no? Oh well, you wrote a nice review!

    (just commenting, please don’t enter me. Thanks!)

  27. Have only read one of Catherine’s books and liked it. This one looks great also and would love to win and read.

  28. I do enjoy Catherine Anderson’s stories. This one looks great also hope lucky like lucky penny…LOL!!

Comments are closed.